top stripe
stripe beneath header

shadow above body
Browse by...
left bar divider

Contact us

Tired of the waste and stupidity? Tell us what you've witnessed.

 

World Views

Brazilians Taming Oil Prices with Ethanol

A massive new fleet of vehicles that can run on ethanol alcohol produced from fermenting sugarcane, gas, or a mixture of the two called flex-fuel vehicles is holding gas prices that are escalating out of control around the world at 2005 prices in Brazil.  

These vehicles, which account for 20 percent of all vehicles in Brazil and 90 percent of new sales, has prevented state oil company Petrobras from charging more for gasoline despite record world oil prices, the company said Friday.

"It doesn't make sense hiking the price of gasoline abruptly if it will cause me a bigger loss of the market than what is already happening today," a Petrobras director told reporters. "It's possible that this year we'll sell more ethanol than gasoline in Brazil."

Unlike hybrids sold in the U.S., flex cars sold in Brazil cost the same as standard models.  In fact, many models only come as flex-cars. And although ethanol engines burn 25 percent more fuel per mile than gasoline, ethanol usually sells at somewhere between a third to half of the price of gas.  In a developing country with the sixth largest population in the world (201 million),  keeping fuel costs down is a major priority.

The flex-fuel trend took seed in 2002 and has grown quickly since.  But the program's origins trace to the early 1980's when Brazil's military government pushed the alcohol-powered vehicles to cut the country's reliance on foreign oil imports and help domestic sugar producers earn a better living.  The initiative required gas stations across the country to add ethanol pumps and between 1983 and 1988, over 88 percent of cars sold annually were running on an ethanol and gasoline medley.

At the close of the 1980's, the government withdrew the subsidies supporting the ethanol program and sugarcane farmers went back to selling sugar, which priced better as a commodity than ethanol.  Falling gas prices in the 1990's left little incentive to use the flex-fuel vehicles, although many taxi drivers continued to fill up with ethanol. 

In 2002, the Brazilian Congress passed a law requiring a blend of ethanol and gasoline at all stations.  It was enough to get car makers tinkering with flex-fuel vehicles once again, only this time market conditions - namely rising oil prices and a growing environmental movement - favored mass production.    

Like Brazil, the U.S. has tinkered with ethanol use for quite some time but without much success.  At present, there are 4 million cars in the U.S. than can run on a blend of up to 85% ethanol and gasoline, but few places offer the fuel.  At present, 10 states don't have a single ethanol or ethanol-gas mix pump and only 1500 such pumps exist around the country. 

The numbers show a lack of seriousness in our policies towards moving away from a petroleum economy.  If a developing country like Brazil could make the move in the 1980's, certainly the world's largest economy can today as well.  Although ethanol, a fuel which requires significant farm land to produce, is hardly a panacea for petroleum addiction, the substitution of the fuel serves as a clear role model for change.  The U.S. must look to and study Brazil's successes and failures in its own attempt to curtail reliance on gasoline. And while a transformation won't happen overnight, it will never happen without major legislation on Capital Hill to subsidize the evolution of our fuel to a completely renewable source.   

 

 


Published Mar 18 2008, 10:04 AM by Andrew B. Einhorn |  Email |  Print



Comments

James said:
"Brazilians taming oil prices ...." - OMG, 18 March 2008. I quote from the article: "a poor country like Brazil ...". Brazil´s domination of the agro-energy question has very little to do with being rich or poor. The production of ethanol from sugar cane has everything to do with devastation of the environment and labour violations that reduce the work force to conditions analogous to slave labour. Full tanks (at the cost of) empty bellies? No thanks!
March 18, 2008 2:48 PM
Andrew B. Einhorn said:
Really, money doesn't matter when the government doles out subsidies to make sure the entire country has ethanol pumps? That's news to me! I guess it will just happen for free here in the U.S. then...and I doubt Brazilians would be filling their bellies with the sugarcane that wasn't used for fuel. Unlike Americans, they are pretty lean.
March 18, 2008 2:51 PM
john said:

If a poor country like Brazil could make the move, certainly the world's largest economy can as well.......

Brazil a poor country? ranking the 8th of the top 10 economies on the world? jesus christ !!!! By the way do you even know where Brazil is located on the map? answer: It' in south america

March 18, 2008 3:36 PM
Becca said:
Brazil is actually the 9th largest economy but in the 1980's, before it started exporting commodities heavily the country was poor. And despite how much the rich make, the standard of living is very poor there - hence the massive deforestation used for slash and burn farming practices. GDP is not the sole indicator of a nation's wealth. Nor is the amount of money it spends on green cars.
March 18, 2008 3:49 PM
Energy For Us All » Flex-fuel cars holding gas prices down in Brazil said:

Pingback from  Energy For Us All » Flex-fuel cars holding gas prices down in Brazil

March 18, 2008 3:52 PM
Matt said:

The only reason Brazil has any money is because it rapes its environment and sells it to China.  But most people there still live in poverty just like in China because there is no middle class.

March 18, 2008 3:54 PM
Andrew B. Einhorn said:
Thank you for all the comments. It's nice to see a dialogue over the issue. A correction on the word "poor" was made, since I had intended it more as a comparison to the U.S. and the general standard of living than the overall state of Brazil's economy. We received the following comment via our contact form. I had attempted to post this before but it made it look like the comment was mine, which is wasn't. From Paul: Really, money doesn't matter when the government doles out subsidies to make sure the entire country has ethanol pumps? That's news to me! I guess it will just happen for free here in the U.S. then...and I doubt Brazilians would be filling their bellies with the sugarcane that wasn't used for fuel. Unlike Americans, they are pretty lean.
March 18, 2008 4:01 PM
DINESH said:
I have personally visited Brazil as a part of representatives of Indian Oil companies which has been contemplating replacating the Brazilian model in India. But what we have understood that simply diverting arable land and resources to produce crops for fuel will only lead to spiralling cost of food. A 'Rich' country like USA will not notice the runaway inflation in Food prices but millions across the globe particularly in Asia and Africa are on the brink of starvation. What is required is to break the cartel of OPEC mainly consisting of Rich Arab rulers. They through thier Oil Money have been fuelling terrorism across the Globe. So 'Ethanol' is not the only panacea for taming Oil prices but other eco-friendly alternative should also be explored in the interest of the Mankind
March 18, 2008 11:46 PM
On The Horizon said:

In 2007, DoD's fighting and transport vehicles in Iraq and Afghanistan drank up more than 55 million

March 19, 2008 10:59 AM

Leave a Comment

 (required)

 
 (optional)

 (required)

 
Add
Inside OhMyGov!

Have your own story or thought to share with others?

We'd love to hear it.  Just send us your story.

If after reviewing it we feel it's web worthy, we'll publish it here.  You get to decide if you want your name on it or not.

We'd like to hear from all branches of government, from the military to the mineral mines.  Stories can be positive or negative accounts; both types are useful for educating (and entertaining) other viewers and fellow feds.  Get started.

Just have a tip to share? Do it securely...

right bar divider
right bar divider
Book Nook

This week's OhMyGov! review:


Gang Leader for a Day: A Rogue Sociologist Takes to the Streets

By Sudhir Venkatesh

 


A proud supporter of:

 

right bar divider
Ten Most Wasted

 2007's biggest tax wasters

#1 DOI Loses $10 Billion in Oil
Revenue
#2 Sen. Feinstein Sells Out to Hollywood
#3 DoD Blows $2.68 Billion

                                                         See All.... 

 

 

right bar divider
far right divider


 

 See All