In the United States, intelligence gathering is a
multi-agency effort. The NSA taps
phones, the DIA analyzes satellite photos, and of course the CIA has its
sneakers on the ground in hot spots like Libya, Iraq, and Afghanistan. But when you're a country with a population the size of New
York City surrounded by mortal enemies and with a skeleton crew of skilled
officers, sometimes you have to improvise.
According to Haaretz, the government of Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu has outsourced monitoring of Palestinian media, social media
and right-wing groups allied with Netanyahu's Likud Party. Among the groups participating in the effort are the
Israeli-based Palestinian Media Watch, the D.C.-based Middle East Media
Research Institute (MEMRI), and other Middle East watchdog organizations.
The decision is mostly economic. Brutal budget cuts mean military officials are unable to
monitor social media and Arab television stations like Al-Jazeera, the
Hezbollah-affiliated Al-Manar, as well as Palestinian media. In some cases, Israel Defense Force
officers get access to crucial Friday sermons in mosques days later - long after
their intelligence value has faded.
The IDF denies the allegations. But staffers and government officials speaking on condition
of anonymity with the Tel-Aviv based newspaper confirm that complaints have
been taken to Military Intelligence Chief Aviv Kochavi, the man tasked with
monitoring email, telephone and web traffic for the IDF's military intelligence
arm.
Incidentally, the IDF has its own social media intelligence
arm, Hatzav. Tasked with
monitoring Twitter, Facebook and other social media websites, the division is
part of Unit 8200, an elite unit of counter-intelligence professionals whose job
is to intercept phone conversations and other suspicious chatter, as well as
beefing up Israel's cybersecurity capabilities.
As resources become increasingly scarce, Prime Minister
Netanyahu's government is taking matters into its own hands. PMW director, Itmar Marcus, has already
come to its aid. Marcus previously
served as a member of the Israeli delegation of the Tri-Lateral Committee to
Monitor Incitement, set up after the signing of the Wye River Memorandum in
1998.
Palestinian Media Watch documents the "contradictions between the image
the Palestinians present to the world in English and the messages to
their own people in Arabic." It documents anti-Jewish and anti-Israel rhetoric on
Palestinian media, distributing translations of Palestinian programs
into English. Information
in the PMW's newsletters frequently find their way into memos; government
and diplomatic officials often cite PMW excerpts during briefings with foreign
dignitaries.
For its part, the Netanyahu government makes an effort to
verify every statement that it cites from PMW memos. But as several high-profile incidents in the region
emphasize the issue of anti-Israel incitement, Netanyahu and his ministers have
no intentions of letting up the pressure on Palestinian officials, clerics and others
it claims are inciting violence in the West Bank and abroad.
Correction: It has come to the attention of the editors that a number
of statements which were included in the original version of this article were misleading or false. The PMW's YouTube channels was shut down for a few days only, not a month. And the shutdown was due to an error by YouTube, as reported above. Additionally, the PMW does not have a "checkered past," nor did the organization have to retract any op-eds it published previously. The information has since been updated with accurate information.