Having trouble incorporating
social media into your government workplace? Unsure of how to use it to
your advantage? You're not alone.
To help government offices
better use the likes of Facebook and Twitter as tools to reach out to citizens
and keep employees better connected, the Center for Technology
in Government at the University at Albany-SUNY has released what it
refers to as the eight essential elements for determining social media
policy in government.
According to the study (pdf), while
there are some high profile examples of government agencies using social
media tools, "for the vast majority of governments across the US,
theses tools are still fairly new and relatively unexplored."
Because of the government's
inexperience with using social media, many agencies are left with the
choice of creating new policies or applying the rules that shape their
policy with other forms of media. This struggle has left many agencies
with rules that don't work, or no real policy at all.
To create these eight
essentials,
the study analyzed the social media policies of 26 different government
agencies, and interviewed 32 government officials who were already
utilizing
social media in the workplace or were considering it. By analyzing
policy,
ranging from the comprehensive New Media and the Air Force
handbook to the simple list of the State of Utah Social Media
Guidelines,
researchers were able to determine what kind of rules were needed
to create an effective policy for social media.
1. The first of these essentials
is determining rules for employee access. According to the study,
the two common methods employers have taken to is either limiting which
employees are allowed to access social media at work or restricting
which sites employees are allowed to access at work. Most choose the
first option, allowing only a select few to access these sites, while
only one of the agencies reviewed allow their employees unfettered
access to all social media. The downside to outright banning these sites
for most employees is that many experts have been able to determine
that some sites, such as YouTube, do have many professional uses, and
its benefits outweigh its risks.
2. For agencies that do
allow employees access, the second essential comes up, which is how
to manage the accounts created for agencies or individuals. Some
states give authority over these to one officer, while others have
multiple
higher-ups who must be consulted for decisions on what these accounts
can or cannot say and do. Because of the information these accounts can
put out on the web, it is very important to establish who is charge
of regulating these accounts.
3. The third essential is
determining
acceptable use for employees accessing accounts online. Many
agencies
are simply using the same rules for social media that govern personal
use of office telephones, etc., but as the line between what's professional vs. personal blurs easily in social media, agencies are having a tougher time
navigating how to regulate use, and how punish violators. Most rules
ban personal use during business hours, but the study suggests that
there is no way to slap a "one-size fits all" policy on how to govern
acceptable use, given the professional interests at hand with social
media.
4. A key one of these essentials
is the fourth one, employee conduct. Distinguishing between the
right and wrong way to use these tools, agencies generally refer to
the already established code of conduct, no racially offensive language,
etc. With others, "trust" is their guideline; employees are
trusted to use their accounts in a professional manner, to represent
the agency in a good light, both on official accounts and on the
employees
personal accounts.
5. A rather open-ended essential
is when it comes to content. Some agencies wield minimum
editorial
control over content, allowing contributors to blog freely. Some are much
tighter
about it. A quote from the Environmental Protection Agency's rules on
content refer to blogging as a "privilege, not a right." If an employee
is on a site such as GovLoop or LinkedIn, discussion about work-related
topics is inevitable, for better or worse. Many agencies instruct their
employees to use disclaimers to separating their opinion from the
agency's.
6. A big concern for agencies
in regards to social media is maintaining security. Due to the
kind of information that can be obtained from faulty security, most
rules deal with passwords, who has them and how they should be
structured.
Many agencies require passwords to be complex, to cut down on the risk
of hacking. Also, regular virus scanning is required in most sets of
rules, sometimes for any post before it hits the Internet. Much of this
worry stems from the fear of both spear phishing and social
engineering --- forms of hacking that hijack information to
manipulate
users.
7. With all of these elements
considered, the possibility arises for legal issues: how
to enforce any of the rules with regards to content and acceptable
usage
without violating areas such as freedom of speech, freedom of
information,
and privacy. Many agencies keep a record of tweets or postings, which
is useful for future review. Another tactic is to utilize disclaimers
to separate the personal from the professional, taking out the need
for review.
8. The last of these essential
elements is citizen conduct. That is, how to deal with the
interaction
with civilian users on social media, who are allowed to post and
contribute
what they wish. Much of the point of using social media is to connect
with the public, but agencies must decide if this kind of interaction
is beneficial to them. In general, agencies have rules that prohibit
any comments that use coarse language, incite violence/illegal activity,
or are spam comments. Some policies use moderators to pre-approve
comments
before they hit the site, using their own discretion on what should
or should not be posted.
Using these essentials, any
agency can craft a policy towards social media that works the best for
the function of the agency. For some, that may even mean no social media
at all. However, for most agencies, interaction with a web-savvy
populace
is an important thing to have, so creating rules that allow this without
compromising the agency itself is key.