Yesterday morning, my Tweetdeck was aflutter
with those anticipating the Health Care Summit. On their way to the Blair House
to meet with Congressmen from both chambers and the President himself for the
eventual seven and a half hour-long debate, some asked their followers what
they wanted to be brought up, and others, like John McCain, put their game
faces on: : "on my way to the health care summit at the White House--let's
start over Mr. President."
Many encouraged their constituents to follow
the debate via C-SPAN in their uniquely Twitterific ways: Representative Joe
Barton's "At
White House about to participate in Health Care Summit with President. It will
be on C-SPAN & other networks possibly" definitely resonates
differently than Senator Chuck Grassley's imperative "On way to White
House/Blair House health care summit. Watch on TV."
Senators Harry
Reid and Chris
Dodd were among
those who tweeted to inform their followers that their staff would be posting
on their behalf during the Summit, respectable in their desires to keep
communication going while not seeming rude or distracted during the summit.
However, for those of us following on Twitter, the real moment we felt included
in the discussion was when Judge Carter tweet-announced "Let the Health
Care Summit begin..."
There was
definitely a whole lot of tweeting going on during the Summit, and I'm guessing
a fair portion of it was not done by staff. A Republican trend emerged that
either @gopconference or @GOPleader (John Boehner) would post a "FACT
CHECK:____" refuting something the President had just said, and a handful
of Republican Congressmen (including Mike Pence, Phil
Gingrey, Bob Latta, would retweet (RT) the blurb.
Representatives Bill Shuster, John
Shimkus, Vern
Buchanan, Bob Latta
posted polls for their followers who were watching the Summit to voice their
opinion/give the Congressmen realtime stats on what his constituents wanted him
to do.
Eventually it was
time for a break, and Chuck Grassley was sure to keep us updated (&
slightly confused): "Broke for lunch fr Summit not bc hungry House had
vote". Representatives Tom Price and John
Shimkus used the break
to tally up minutes of talk-time; as Representative Shimkus put it, "Time clock
on first half of healthcare summit: Dems spoke for 108 min, GOP spoke for 56
minutes. Who's doing the listening?"
Things really
started to get juicy in both the latter half and aftermath of the Summit. More
than anything, the tweets reflect continued Republican sentiment of being
"left out", in spite of the bipartisan circumstances of the Summit.
Nonetheless, emotions were stirred, and the following are some highlights to
that effect:
• The most retweeted post of the day was Jim DeMint's "After a year pretending Republicans
don't have health care ideas, the President just admitted we do. #tcot #gop #hcr"
• Senator DeMint was also really diligent to add links
to the end of his tweets yesterday. The post "President says he's open to
GOP ideas but he voted against them when he was in the Senate" was
followed by a link to a laundry list on his website of past Republican health
care reform initiatives that Senator Obama voted against. However, his most
interesting linked post was "Obama & Reid still open to
reconciliation. If it they try to ram this through, I'll use every tool to stop
it" where he linked to a post on his blog entitled "Irreconcilable
Differences", implying that the Republicans and the
Democrats/President/healthcare bills are getting divorced. What happened to
staying together for the kids?
• Randy Neugebauer took the posted link one step
further: he linked to a youtube video. "It's time to stop politicizing
health care and start an honest conversation with the American people"
a link to a short film where he is sitting alone with a camera,
really breaking that fourth wall and speaking directly to his constituent,
telling them what they want through aptly linked talking points.
• David
Vitter drove home a
common theme: that the healthcare plan ignores what "the people" want
(although the only answer to "what they want" that I've heard is
lower cost which seems a bit reductive). "Healthcare Summit proves Obama
& fellow liberals not listening to the people #LAsen #latcot #tcot #gop#teaparty"
which (look at all those trending topics!) he followed with a link to his
facebook page that had a longer version of the same rant.
• Chris Dodd posted a few resonating statistics, a
breath of fresh air among the blood pressure-raising FACT CHECKS and calls to
start over. "In the next ten years, without reform, every state will have
a 10% increase in the number of uninsured. #hcr" and "Coverage is
essential--14,000 people lose their health insurance every day."
• Lamar Smith believes that
healthcare is done: "#TCOT Obama is holding wrong summit. Health
care summit today is too little, too late http://lamarsmith.house.gov/read.aspx?ID=1309".
• Patrick McHenry, among his
various invitations for people to watch the Summit and tweet-chat with him
about it, also tried to make a few jokes. Some included "Nancy Pelosi just
claimed a government takeover of health care will create jobs "immediately"...
I'm having pre-stimulus vote flashbacks...", and "Cutting Medicare to
fund new entitlements won't save Medicare or reduce the deficit. Double-entry
accounting didn't work for Madoff either."
• Don Young thought he could be funny as well: "The
president's health care proposal is like giving a kid a bowl of brussel
sprouts, stirring it around, and calling it ice cream. #hcsummit"
• Mike
Honda's supportive
tweet seemed comical amid so many negative ones, but his positivity is
definitely charming: "Health summit: glad focus is on the ppl and lowering
costs, not politics. Effective bi-partisanship? I love our President! #HCR #summit"
It's interesting
that amongst claims that the Summit was a media circus or, as Patrick McHenry
put it, "political theatre [that] continues to blur the line between DC and
Broadway," those who were denouncing the Summit as such were the ones
tweeting in ways that mimicked peanut galleries at, well, circuses and plays.
Nonetheless, the standout tweet of the day was a diamond in the rough, because
one needed to follow Thad McCotter's posted link to
get the punchline: "In a time of war and recession, this is how the
duly elected leaders of the greatest nation on Earth spent their day,"
followed by a link to a blog post entitled: Shamwow Summit.