A recent Gallup survey of nearly 42,000 Americans conducted to examine
public attitudes about the "overall customer experience" across all
federal agencies found that Americans are generally not satisfied with the performance of government
agencies, save for the military.
Nearly half of Americans polled viewed federal agencies neutrally (46 percent), with significantly more negative views (34 percent) than positive ones (20 percent).
By stark contrast, the military fared well in the poll, as 78
percent expressed positive views of its performance.
Interestingly, the highest rated agency
was the National Park Service with a 90 percent satisfaction rating. Perhaps fresh air really is the key to success.
Of special mention, the Environmental Protection Agency,
Internal Revenue Service, and Health and Human Services Department were among
those ranked lowest in customer satisfaction, although HHS and the Social Security Administration were seen having the greatest potential impact on the daily lives of those polled.
When asked
which agency is most important to the future of the country, the Department of
Defense (DoD) stood out again with the Department of Education a close second. Surprisingly the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Department of Agriculture were tied for the lowest rating.
A Little Branding Goes a Long Way
According to
the survey, the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) was viewed as the employer of
choice, that is, the agency they would most want to work for. A far cry from the EPA who took another
last place seat. Clearly the mystique
of covert activities like those seen on "Splinter Cell" video games or the action
hero's like Vince Flynn novels featuring Mitch Rapp have better appeal than the perceived bureaucrat pushing a piece of paper or gathering an environmental sample, which
leads to the survey's golden nugget: branding and image building.
The survey identified
an opportunity for the federal agencies to build a positive brand image in the
eyes of Americans. Not that a survey was needed, since government blunders like Hurricane Katrina, the Challenger, and most recently the
deployment of the H1N1 vaccine remain in the forethoughts of most Americans. But the survey does provide empirical evidence for
agency leadership to understand the necessity to brand and market their agencies, especially as government is trying to recruit and retain talent.
While the survey
found awareness of most agencies was high, it did not equate to a positive
brand or a differentiation between agencies. Given the importance of public perceptions and their impact on brand
image, this may be one of the more insightful pieces of information to gleam
from the study. Unfortunately, government leaders typically do not see
the merit in branding themselves as Coke, Budweiser, or other notable brands like
Google, beyond their annual request to convince Congress for their share of limited government funds during appropriations hearings.
Limited Interaction With Agencies Confounds Results
Interestingly, the survey reveled
that most interactions with the federal government were either to visit a national park,
monument, or historic landmark, or to pass through a border checkpoint, customs
control, or airport security. This lack of direct interaction with the vast majority of other government agencies we depend on daily also makes the case for agency investment in branding to make
the public aware of the other two million federal employees (including USPS) and the importance of their services.
In measuring satisfaction through direct interaction with agency, Gallop looked at measures such as, delivering on promises, treating people with respect, and providing accurate information. They also looked at transactional assessments, such as the time it takes to get a response, the ability to connect with a live person, problem resolution, availability, treatment, and follow through.
So what's the take home
message of all this?
The government needs to find better ways to measure performance, improve
customer service and do a better job of marketing and branding.
Read More: Agriculture (USDA),
Defense (DoD),
Education (ED),
Energy (DOE),
Health And Human Services (HHS),
Homeland Security (DHS),
Transportation Security Administration (TSA),
National Park Service (NPS),
Justice (DOJ),
Labor (DOL),
State (DOS),
Treasury,
Internal Revenue Service (IRS),
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA),
National Aeronautics And Space Administration (NASA),
U.S. Congress,
Management Tips,
Morale