Follow OhMyGov! on  OhMyGov on Facebook

  JOIN  or  LOGIN    ALSO ON OMG! : GET SOCIAL
720923

Migrants in Hawaii get government healthcare, do you?

Lava them not, Hawaii does, after spending $100 million a year

By Mark Cantora Sep 02 2009, 11:01 AM

Palau paradise

Palau paradise

As if there weren't already enough angles, arguments, and standpoints on the health insurance debate, Hawaii now brings us a curious new loophole involving citizens from islands you've never heard of.

If you're one of the 48 million Americans without health insurance, you will scratch your head ... and consider buying a plane ticket. And if you're angry over the billions of taxpayer dollars Uncle Sam may spend on a "public option," this will only fuel your outrage.

Since 1986, three small Pacific island nations—Palau, the Marshall Islands, and the Federated States of Micronesia—have been in a unique transnational agreement with the U.S. that has resulted in the government spending millions on healthcare for non-U.S. citizen migrants.

The agreement between the U.S. and the island states is known as the Compact of Free Association, which was initially enacted as an economic, security, and restitutionary measure to repay the islanders for the nuclear testing and storage that took place there since the 1940s.

Simply stated, COFA allows for citizens of the three nations to live and work as legal migrants in the U.S. without having to go through the typical arduous process to attain legal migrant status. But COFA doesn't addresses the key issue of healthcare... something the government ignored or overlooked when setting up the agreement.

And here's where the problems arise. Because of its close proximity to the three COFA nations, Hawaii is a popular migratory destination for COFA nation citizens, and the state now spends over $100 million annually in services on them, the largest portion of which goes to education and health benefits.

Sounds like a nagging COFA

While COFA states that jurisdictions whom accept COFA migrants should not experience any adverse consequences, the federal government only reimburses Hawaii $11 million annually.  This results in an $89 million deficit that must be shouldered by residents of our 50th state.

In the past few months, after years of paying for health benefits for its legal non-citizen COFA residents, Hawaii decided to get its house in order. The state passed a Health Reform plan that would remove many of the COFA migrants from state health coverage. Although rumors of taking patients off of critical dialysis and chemotherapy treatments have turned out to be false, many COFA migrant residents will fall outside the scope of any government-run healthcare—they will be ineligible for state healthcare and have been ineligible for federal Medicaid benefits since 1996.

Interestingly, the federal government has since stepped in and offered to pay millions of dollars to Hawaii over the next two years, in order that Hawaii may continue funding COFA residents' healthcare.

So to recap: If you are a U.S. citizen without health insurance, what is the best way to receive it? Answer: Renounce your citizenship, move to Palau, then move back to Hawaii as a non-citizen migrant, and the government will hook you up. Sounds easy enough, no?

 

Read More: Healthcare, You Paid For It!, What The Gov, Hawaii

 
 
 
Submit
COMMENT

Niki
September 2, 2009 11:22 AM

The original agreement seems like a good gesture. so i guess we're still paying the costs of all the nuke testing we did there. i don't mind this but it is weird they are covered when so many other Americans aren't

David
September 3, 2009 1:37 PM

Palau and the FSM didn't endure the atomic testing (aside from maybe a little drifing fallout). The RMI has a lot of internal migrants as a result of the contaminated areas and U.S. base at Kwajalein. The extent of the health impact of the testing is open to debate, as is the lasting economic legacy of being U.S. Trust Territories for decades. The U.S. does enjoy/purchase (close to exclusive) strategic access to huge swaths of the Pacific as a result of its support of these nations. Although Hawaii is making the most noise, there are a lot of Micronesian migrants in other states (Arkansas, Utah, California, Oregon and Oklahoma.)

John
September 4, 2009 9:48 AM

Until you have cleaned up their home lands from Nuclear condamination, and give them back their lives, you and your government must take care of these people, especially those who came from the Marshall Islands. These are peacefull nations, didn't ask for your Nuclear testing, you destroyed their lands and took their lives away from them. They sacrified their God's given right to live in their own peaceful lands for a peaceful world, so they were told. If you don't know it yet, the people from the four atolls that were really effected by your Nuclear testing have not gone back to their home lands yet, why? because they are still condaminated and full of radiation from these fallouts. The biggest one was the CODE name BRAVO. One thousand times more stronger that what you dropped on Nakasaki and Hiroshima combined. I suggest you all study and learn what your country did to these people before you LAVA them out. You destroyed their Lands, period.. Mr. Mark Cantora, if you are such a good writer, as I suspect you think you are, do your home works on these people and see how your country destroyed them during the Nuclear years from 1946 to 1957. Total of 87 Nuclear testing were conducted on these people and their Islands. How would you feel if these testings were in your back Yards?? Its been almost 60 years since the Bravo test, and your government is refusing to clean up these islands. Mr. MarkCantora, the least you can do is grant them healthcare, they are not going to be around much longer.

Annie
September 4, 2009 10:55 AM

Mr. Mark Cantora, should they kick your government and Military Base out of Kwajalein? These people are kind enough to allow your Military to stay on their Island. There is no other Missile Range between Far East and Hawaii. If China and/or North Korea decide to Launch Missiles toward Hawaii, guess who encounter-Kwajalein, Marshall Islands. Just so you know, Ronald Reagan Pacific Missile Range is located on Kwajalein. It stands between lives and death of everyone in Hawaii should Mr. Kim decide to launch. Where is RRPMR? In the Marshall Islands, Mr. Cantora.. And you are refusing a little Healthcare for these people and want to LAVA them out?

Ri-Majol
September 9, 2009 4:39 PM

now that the U.S. is a nuclear super- power they forget about the people the PEOPLE THAT THEY TOOK ADVANTAGE FOR WHAT THEY SAID CLAIMED AS "FOR THE GOOD OF MANKIND" PLS. TRY TO LEARN MORE OF THE HISTORY OF HOW THE U.S BECAME SUCH A SUPER POWER. ISLANDERS WERE SUFFERING DURING SUCH COLD WAR ERA.

RI-MAJOL
September 9, 2009 4:46 PM

THIS WRITES SHOULD GO BACK TO SCHOOL AND LEARN HIS HISTORY!

Ethel
September 13, 2009 12:44 AM

So Mr. Cantora, you never heard of the Micronesian Islands, huh!! They used to be called, the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands. Territories under the United States of America, remember??How can anyone lives in Hawaii claim to be that stupid, let alone a Journalist, or are you that so ignorant!! Let me enlighten your Pacific Islands geographical knowledge.. The Micronesian Islands are located at the central Pacific Ocean, or little bit to the western Central Pacific, almost due southwest of Honolulu, due north of New Zealand, East of Guam, couple Latitude lines above the Equator. That put these Islands in the Central Pacific Ocean, I'd say!! Closer to the Hawaian Islands,or didn't you know that Mr. Cantora, what a shame!! Before you shoot these Micronesians down with the power of your pen, you must look at your back yards. You will see that beside the locals, you've got mix breeds, people from everywhere. How did they get to Hawaii to be called Hawaiians? We were all immigrants once, Mr. Cantora, give them a break!! Your Military and government Bombed their Lands with your powerful Atom bombs, telling them it was "For the good of all mankind" that the Nuclear testing must be done. They sacrificed and lend you their lands for Nuclear testing. Your Government took away their way of lives, they don't have anything left. They can't go home to Contaminated, and poisonous lands. Why can we sacrificed a little for them?Put yourself in ther shoes. Either your government clean up their lands from contamination from Nuclear radiation, or help them out. Its the right thing to do!!

Missing the Point
September 16, 2009 11:21 AM

It seems as if many of the comments are missing the point. The article is not critical of the United States giving government health-care to citizens of Micronesia, Palau, and the Marshall Islands. Obviously these people deserve to be treated with respect and dignity, and in many cases probably do deserve to have the United States fund their health-care as a restitutionary measure. But the article's argument is not critical of the COFA citizen's receiving healthcare. The article's argument is, "Why should the COFA migrants receive healthcare while many Americans DO NOT." One could argue (similar to many of the other commenters) that many Americans whose grandparents and ancestors were slaves or soldiers fighting for America, or any other category of people who have made sacrifices (intentional or not) for American prosperity deserve healthcare, and yet they still do not. So, it seems that the commenters getting worked up over the article's alleged misunderstanding of history or ignorance of the plight of Pacific Islanders are merely missing the point of the article. Put more simply, the article argues, "WHETHER OR NOT COFA migrants deserve to have government healthcare (which it seems, and the article never disputes, that they do), shouldn't US citizens who have/are/or will sacrifice for the United States be receiving AT LEAST as good healthcare/treatment as COFA migrants? That is the argument.

John
September 20, 2009 3:12 AM

I don't think anybody missed the point here. These comments were from the people who just want to clearify the fact that there is a reason why the Island Nations people should get the healthcare they deserve from the US Government. Its obvious to me that the writer didn't do his home works on this particular group of people from the Islands before he wrote the column. It seems to me that anyone live and work in Hawaii, or an Hawaiian should know where the Micronesian islands are, don't you think??  The comparation should not have been made between the Americans people and these Islanders who came here to seek help because of the Nuclear testing and radiation fallouts on their home land.  The comparation should be made between the working population and the Non-working population here in the United States.

The policy of this land we call, the United States of America is, you work for it and you will get it. Many Americans don't get healthcare because they don't work and therefore don't have healthcare. If the President get his wish, then we will have healthcare for these kind of people, working or not, you and I will pay for their Medical bills, trust me.   Why should we working people pay for these non-working population's healthcare, May I ask.

                                                     The different between the Island Nations people and the NON-WORKING population here in the US is that, we dropped nuclear clear bomb and radiation fallouts on these people and condaminated their lands PERIOD, The others group mentioned above, I don't know. Like I said, if the President get his wish, maybe we will have healthcare for all Amercians.

 

         

 

 

                JOIN THE COMMUNITY!
 
 

 

Melissa: " One of the things I would like to bring up is that fact that if we spend less than ...  more Melissa: " think it's ironic that the republicans and neocons who bitch the most about imm...  more Melissa: Illegals do so get free healthcare, they also get welfare which welfare PROVIDES medi-cal ...  more

About OhMyGov!

The most fun government news has ever been...

Read More
Press Coverage

Site Tools

An array of helpful, fun features is coming soon!


Friends

We're on Facebook and Twitter: @OhMyGov
and @Bureaupat

See Our Partners