Is Iran the first Twitter revolution? One post to the
microblogging service told readers how to make a homemade gas mask in the event
of tear gas. Another informed the world that demonstrators were being scared
off the streets by Revolutionary Guard patrols. These are just two of many “tweets” helping Iranians spread
information about demonstrations against the recent election results that kept
President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in power.
The short text messages sent via cell phones and the web are
giving an unlikely movement added momentum and coordination as the
demonstrations head into their second week in Tehran.
Twitter, the microblogging social media website, is being
hailed for its role in helping Iranians disseminate information in a time where
authorities are tightening their already iron-grip on the media and free
speech. Though the Iranian government is expert at online suppression, it is
struggling to censor Twitter.
Any mass movement in Iran would garner attention from the
United States regardless of tactics, but the role of Twitter is adding intrigue
and (possibly overstated) exuberance for spectators here. The State Department
claimed Monday that it
asked the website to perform scheduled maintenance during the nighttime in Iran,
maximizing access to protestors. This claim is disputed by some who perceive
the Obama administration as
taking undue credit; it is also seen as too meager by those who think the
United States should step up intervention.
Knowing full well the history of failed intervention in
Iran, the Obama administration is reluctant to say too much of anything about
the movement. Interference by the “Great Satan” could hinder the movement, the
president pointed out. Although he voiced he support for human rights in Iran,
he reiterated the need for the United States to respect Iranian sovereignty.
Interference could be counterproductive in the country
itself, as Iran and hardliner sympathizers could raise hell in Afghanistan and
Iraq. Military intervention of some kind falls somewhere between implausible
and impossible. Foreign involvement could hand the Iranian government a rare
propaganda victory, even if against odds it actually prevented an Iranian Tiananmen.
Many, however, are still calling for President Obama to take
a more aggressive approach, with some mistakenly
believing the movement to be a rare display of pro-Americanism. Even if Iranians did want more support
from the White House (they
don’t), given the impracticality of intervening, ratcheting up fiery
rhetoric could be a virtual death sentence for Iranian dissidents. Just like
the government sponsored Radio Free Europe gave Hungarian revolutionaries the
false impression that NATO troops had their backs in 1956 (pdf), tough
talk from Washington again could condemn Iranian dissidents to the same fate.
And although ruling out further diplomatic action against the Iranian regime
would be foolish, the administration should pat itself on the back for its
policy of limited intervention, employed wisely, if true, in the case of
Twitter.
Government support for new forms of media should be
tempered. Whereas traditional media used in the past to foment protest
movements came from the top down, Twitter is a vessel for information from
individual users — a true, if sometimes silly, expression of democracy. If the
United States wishes to truly lead the world in democracy, it must, among other
things, let media 2.0 do its own thing.
Though this era of more democratized media, far from perfect
it may be, is exciting websites like Twitter alone will
not lead to sweeping changes in Iran, or anywhere else for that
matter. Whether it comes from a
protestor or politician — in this country or Iran — talk is cheap and cannot
fight a revolution. Where that talk is expressed in 140 characters of text, it
can certainly help those who may be fighting it. Realizing that true change
comes from within, making sure that line of communication is open for Iranians
is a savvy move from the White House.
Also Interesting:
[+] Feds freeze over $30 million of online poker winnings
[+] The Fog of Wartime Contracting: An OhMyGov! In-Depth Report
[+] The week's 10 best political jokes - June 19, 2009
[+] DARPA developing translation device
[+] In Daniel Hauser Case, Liberty Suffers Too
[+] Stupid license plate earns Chicago man 170 tickets