An all-new OhMyGov! is here...

  JOIN  or  LOGIN    ALSO ON OMG! : GET SOCIAL
040710

Americans pose tough questions for Obama...about marijuana

By Andrew B. Einhorn Dec 12 2008, 10:45 AM

The Obama camp, in its continuing efforts to open up the dialogue between the government and its citizens, recently launched a new website feature on the transition team's website Change.gov that allows anyone to pose a question to the Obama team. Other visitors who like the question can then vote it up or down in Digg.com fashion, depending on whether or not they think the question is important and would like to see it answered quickly.

In an economy as tumultuous as this one, you might expect the top question to be how Obama will fix the economy, create jobs, restore the stock market to stable levels, or handle the mounting pile of debt added weekly by Congressional bailouts of industry. But you'd be wrong if you did.

Instead, the most popular question to the Obama administration was whether or not the President-elect plans to legalize marijuana. That's right, throw the economy, eliminating our oil addiction, handling terrorism and ending two wars out the window because Americans just want to smoke their pot and eat it too. 

"Will you consider legalizing marijuana so that the government can regulate it, tax it, put age limits on it, and create millions of new jobs and create a billion dollar industry right here in the U.S.?" asked a man from Denton, Ohio. 

This top question, one of over 10,000 posed, has received nearly 8,000 "up" votes out of about one million votes cast from those who would also like an answer to it. 

Another popular question - the seventh most popular on the website - inquires about Obama's stance on medical marijuana.

"13 states have compassionate use programs for medial Marijuana, yet the federal gov't continues to prosecute sick and dying people. Isn't it time for the federal gov't to step out of the way and let doctors and families decide what is appropriate?" asked Greg from Minnesota.

Similarly, Bruce from Fort Collins, CO inquired how much longer the U.S. would wage a winless war against drugs.

The US "War on Drugs" wastes billions every year tracking down and incarcerating non-violent users. What is your position on the legalization of marijuana? How do you feel about treating rather than imprisoning users of harder, addictive drugs?"

What exactly these trends say about Americans is nebulous at best. Given Obama's popularity among young adults and their proclivity to find cool websites faster than an Illinois politician can get in trouble, it's likely the data is skewed to overrepresent this group whose nightly habits don't quite mirror Joe the Plumber's. 

On the other hand, Americans might just be fed up with politics as usual and are looking to sit back, relax, and watch their retirement funds disappear through a comfortable fog without being hassled by police.

Of course, not everyone on the site was consumed solely by their desires for legalizing the wacky tobacco. The second most popular question on the site with 6,000 "up" votes asked about restoring Constitutional powers from a woman in Seattle.

"What will you do as President to restore the Constitutional protections that have been subverted by the Bush Administration and how will you ensure that our system of checks and balances is renewed?" asked Kari from Seattle.

Following her serious lead, Diane from New Jersey's question about how the new administration will handle bailout oversight also stirred quite a bit of support.  Likewise, James from Nashville's question about whether Obama will eliminate the stem-cell research ban within his first 100 days in office elicited nearly 5,500 up votes. 

In total, 10,303 questions received nearly one million votes from 20,500 people. And even if the respondent population is skewed to bias particular policy areas, one thing is clear: the experiment in digital democracy seems a success.

 

Also Interesting:


 

Read More: Others

 
 
 
Submit
COMMENT

Pete Guither
December 12, 2008 12:59 PM

It's irresponsible reporting like this that has Americans fed up. It's not just about being able to have their wacky tobacco that drives these questions. And it's definitely not: "On the other hand, Americans might just be fed up with politics as usual and are looking to sit back, relax, and watch their retirement funds disappear through a comfortable fog without being hassled by police." If you had read the questions better you'd realize that their concern is also that the war on drugs has permeated and damaged all of society. People can get pot now if they want -- they don't need legalization for that. What they want is better use of their government (and tax money) instead of wasting it going after pot smokers and sick grandmothers, while making the black market more profitable. They want an economy that isn't prison-based. They want foreign policy that isn't about pushing our failed drug wars on everyone else. They want inner cities that aren't ruled by drug gangs making profits off the black market. These are serious questions deserving serious answers, not your childish sniggering. If you want to laugh about pot jokes, go watch a Cheech and Chong movie. These folks showing up at change.gov are interested in real solutions.

Chuck
December 12, 2008 1:27 PM

Obama implemented Open for Questions to entertain questions that he might not otherwise answer from the press and media. The economy, wars, and other issues are more important, but they are all over the networks. Legalizing marijuana is an issue rarely addressed in the political arena, so given the chance, the internet community will rise to force this issue into mainstream discussion time and time again until something is done about it. There is also the fact that legalizing marijuana and hemp could help restore our economy from the bottom up, rather than trying to mend our current crisis by funneling trillions of dollars to failing financial institutions from the top down. This is not about blowing smoke in our living rooms watching the world around us collapse, it's about being realistic and sensible with our policies, and encouraging market places that we know can succeed, and not encouraging the ones that have already failed.

Cal
December 12, 2008 2:04 PM

Lighten up man, it's Friday! The guy was trying to be funny! The site is called OhMyGov! not Crooks and Liars. If you read the other articles listed underneath, you'll see them actually addressing marijuana issues in a much more intelligent way. Besides, I don't think it's so bad to point out that when given the chance to raise new issues, Americans can only think about smoking weed instead of say, eliminating the debt, fixing social security, implementing health care reforms, moving to electronic medical records, fighting poverty and crime in america, etc. It is pretty funny...and sad. Don't get me wrong, I want weed legalized too. But will that solve our problems, or simply create another wing of HHS to deal with the hemp huggers?

Fred Kruk
December 12, 2008 2:06 PM

Yes marijuana should be legal, but it is not a top issue or deserving of the limelight right now. After all, legalizing weed would just mean out of work drug dealers...another group the fed will have to bailout.

Redford Givens
December 12, 2008 3:10 PM

By ending drug prohibition, Obama can divert more than $100 BILLION per year to more worthwhile purposes, like health care, social security etc

That's  $100 BILLION per year every year from now on.

No new taxes, just a reassignment of funding.

mark
December 12, 2008 3:44 PM

pete and chuck..kudos

John
December 12, 2008 4:50 PM

Cal, actually legalizing, taxing and regulating marijuana would directly affect some of the other issues. It would reduce crime, since the police, who waste billions of dollars chasing around people who have a samll amount of an herb on them, can persue real crime and cut down on the violent crimes that are so pevalent in America these days. It would also create a multi billion dollar industry which would employ tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of out of work people, thus giving our economy the boost it desperately needs and helping to fight at least some of the poverty. It will also free up prisons for actual criminals, and save billions more that we spend housing non-violent offenders. Did you know that quite often murderers and rapists are released from prison long before those there for drug possession due to mandatory minimum sentences for drug offenders?

cal
December 12, 2008 5:02 PM

yeah, it's all true but how much of that $100B will go to treating pot addicts, developing new technologies so police can detect high drivers, enforcing under 21 pot smoking laws, health care expenditures and emergency response for those involved in accidents, and policing drug dealers who used to deal pot and now deal heroin. Too many questions abound. That's why the issue remains untouched.

Okinkun
December 12, 2008 5:31 PM

An interesting bit, there were around 15 Marijuana related questions within the top 50, with almost 30,000 votes between them all.

Food for thought. lol

Yes, it may not be the most pressing important issue out there... BUT it is still a very important issue. The failed drug war is responsible for billions of wasted tax dollars, millions in jail needlessly for the non-violent crime of using pot on their own body.

If we legalized it, we could FINALLY properly regulate it, set age limits, gain a new industry with pot and hemp, new jobs, and billions in taxes.

This issue could be a HUGE plus to our economy and country, if we considered legalization. It is at the heart of MANY other issues... A core problem at the base, which if we fix, will effect things above it very positively!

Pete Guither
December 12, 2008 5:36 PM

Cal, I understand that it's Friday and he was trying to be funny, but in fact, there are a lot of people who are constantly working with the tragedies and the damage of the drug war who are tired of always being a joke. It's old, quite frankly, to have every effort to have real conversations about drug policy reform met with bong jokes. 800,000 people were arrested last year for marijuana offenses. That isn't funny. We have the highest incarceration rate in the world. That isn't funny. Drugs are being sold to children and are unsafe due to lack of regulation. That isn't funny. And Cal, there are answers to your questions about pot addicts and health care expenditures and accidents, etc. Plenty of answers, but nobody ever is willing to have a real dialog about them because every time someone says pot, it becomes a munchies joke. This is serious stuff, and the politically active (not sitting on Pete's couch) group that showed up at change.gov is not going to put up with being a joke anymore (or do nothing while people say that there are unanswered questions, so there's no point in having a discussion!)

cal
December 12, 2008 6:29 PM

About 12 states have already decriminalized it. I'd hardly say it was underrepresented in conversation. What remains to be seen is the longitudinal effect of that decriminalization on those states. I don't disagree we need marijuana reform. I simply disagree it's the #1 issue in the country, as represented on Change.gov. The powers int he Obama camp asked the people to tell them something new, to bring up ideas from the people and not the podium, and all they got was we want our drugs. Yes, jail time is wasted on pot users and the war on pot is a joke. But the point of the article and my point is that we should have better things to wish for from our government.

John
December 12, 2008 8:00 PM

I look at their sites open question forum more for people looking to get answers about Obamas stance on issues that wouldn't otherwise be covered by the mainstream media.  This is definitely one of the #1 issues that is "not likely to be asked by any major media outlet".  This is also one of those issues that he has been wishy-washy on over the years, and has yet to clarify his actual position on thus far.

Pete Guither
December 12, 2008 11:14 PM

The point of Change.gov is not to find the #1 issue in the country.  Hopefully Obama doesn't need a website vote to figure out that the economy is in the tank or that we're at war.  I mean, duh.

The point of Change.gov is to give grassroots voice to the people and, in particular, find those points of view that they feel are not being represented by their government.  And so, having marijuana laws as the #1 issue is perfectly appropriate.

The fact that 12 states have decriminalized it (and 13 have legalized medical marijuana) and the FEDERAL government is still unwilling to even talk about it is proof that this conversation needs to take place.

And I don't think we have better things to wish for from our government than to do something about a very corrupt government drug war industry that harms individuals, enriches corrupt officials and traffickers, and destroys the Constitution.

It's not about wanting our drugs.  We can get them now.  46% of the American population has used illegal drugs and they didn't need legalization to do it.  It's about the federal government being willing to discuss damaging drug laws.

Thetruth
December 13, 2008 6:26 AM

Well, surprise imbecile- the biggest non-democratic assault on the value of American citizenship is the damn drug war. What pharmaceutical drugs are you on to make you not realize the travesty of democracy and the sham of human rights created by illegal marijuana?

Nobody wants it illegal except for the retarded and the retarded that work for the government.

Hope
December 13, 2008 7:46 AM

Cal, you said, "The powers int he Obama camp asked the people to tell them something new, to bring up ideas from the people and not the podium, and all they got was we want our drugs. Yes, jail time is wasted on pot users and the war on pot is a joke." <p> You still aren't hearing. <p> The people who posted those questions and voted them up, are NOT saying "We want our drugs." They are saying , "WE DO NOT WANT THIS DANGEROUS, EXPENSIVE, PUNITIVE, AND, OFTEN, DEADLY PROHIBITION". <p> Why can't you hear that without twisting it into an insult or slur to those who say it?. <p> "The war on pot is a joke."  It's not a very funny joke. Handcuffs, humiliation, human cages, criminal records, outrageous fines and fees,  and serious persecution at the hands of government. Not very funny at all.

Andrew B. Einhorn
December 13, 2008 9:00 AM

This was emailed to me:

"my son is addicting to pot. he smokes all day, never goes out, and has no motivation or brainpower most of the time. He's been in and out of treatment centers for his addiction. Why should this awful drug be legal?"

ezrydn
December 13, 2008 9:41 AM

I am an American who lives in Mexico.  While you hear of atrocities in Iraq and the Middle East, you seem to not notice the exact same thing going on just south of your border.  

Even as you equate the Cartels with Al Qeada, you don't really see the problem.

It's not about marijuana, or heroin or cocaine, per se.  Those items were legally sold in every drug store in America around the 1900s without the problems of today.  It's about "POLICY."  Will a policy change affect the cartels?  You betcha!  And it can be done without guns, bullets, lives or Plan Mexico.  We're giving Mexico $1.4B dollars to fight cartels that make $40 - 100 Billion a year?  That's not help!  Over 5,000 people, many of them children, have been slaughtered because "Policy" makes it so.  The cartels aren't afraid of laws, governments, helicopters or anything else we can throw at them.  A policy change, on the other hand, suddenly strips them of any future profits and they must then seek a new "product."

The US has handed the cartels the "golden goose" and wants no portion of it's "golden eggs."  Meantime, we sink deeper into economic turmoil and gather the hatred of neighboring countries.   And you joke about it?  It's gotta be "you're stupid" or "you don't care."  Which is it?

Red
December 13, 2008 9:46 AM

And what was the second most asked question? What will restore constitutional rights? Well, getting rid of the phony "war on drugs" would help restore a great deal of them. I guess citizens know when they've had enough. Oh, and Mr. Einhorn, the answer to your question is, because pot is NOT addictive.

jackl
December 13, 2008 10:06 AM

The drug should be legal so that your son will not end up with a criminal record, jail time or other punitive sanctions that will harm him his entire life in a much more profound way than the pot smoking you complain about.  Also, did you notice that pot being illegal hasn't stopped your son or anyone else from easily finding pot on the black market.

In other news, Pete's response here correct; Cal = clueless.

jackl
December 13, 2008 10:06 AM

The drug should be legal so that your son will not end up with a criminal record, jail time or other punitive sanctions that will harm him his entire life in a much more profound way than the pot smoking you complain about. Also, did you notice that pot being illegal hasn't stopped your son or anyone else from easily finding pot on the black market. In other news, Pete's response here correct; Cal = clueless.

Alex M
December 13, 2008 4:05 PM

This article is juvenile. Wow, so you can marginalize a huge segment of America with sarcastic humor. The war on drugs is a failure, and it's not about Marijuana. The author fails to see that ending prohibition is less about Marijuana and more about sane government. You let your personal opinions and stupid politics and superstitions get in the way of talking seriously and rationally about issues lots of people take seriously. Many hard-working Americans do take it seriously, whether you want to believe it or not.

Andrew B. Einhorn
December 13, 2008 5:21 PM

Great discussion. Thanks to all for commenting. For the record, I think marijuana should be legalized and feel the war against it is an absurd, winless policy spawned by a ridiculous 1936 film. I have covered the issue in various ways, ranging from serious to humorous in an effort to drive the point home to different audiences. The article above highlights an unusual trend I spotted and wanted to call attention to in a light-hearted way.  Keep on the lookout for more thought-provoking pieces on the topic, a few of which were listed at the end of the article.

Tony
December 14, 2008 11:39 PM

You are a terrible journalist. Learn how to report news without being slanted and biased. I could care less about your opinion. Just tell facts, please.

Mary Ann
December 15, 2008 9:06 AM

Tony - no one cares about your opinion. It's clear you aren't smart enough to even be reading the news. There's no reason to be a jerk. I thought the article was very interesting. Go be a curmudgeon someplace else.

steve
December 15, 2008 9:07 AM

Kudos to pete.  I read your blog almost daily and you always give a strong well spoken response to lies and rhetoric spewing from the national media.

Tammy
December 26, 2008 6:41 PM

Usually if someone uses marijuana, aka cannabis, it is for reasons we often do not see. I know a man who cannot stomach most prescription pills. He has tried them all. This one made him dangerously ill, that one made him sleep for three days and that one made him cranky, agitated and angry. Give the same man a bit of sativa and his anxiety lessens and he begins acting like himself again. That man has Asperger's Syndrome (autism) and the only thing he has found, after 20 years of searching, that helps slow his mind and relax his anxiety without making him ill or changing his mood is medical Marijuana. I have known cancer patients that cannot take the prescription medications without vomiting, losing their appetite or becoming a total zombie. Yet, that same person eats or smokes medical indica cannabis and they are able to eat without the vomiting and they act like someone who is not in pain. This is not about us wanting our drugs, this about a better quality of life.

It is a fact that the revenue generated by legalization would definitely be a big step toward actually changing the future economic outlook of this country. Those of you that name call and make jokes are helping nothing. In fact, the joke is on you. These are real people dying of real diseases and the one universal plant can be used to treat them, is illegal.

This not only about the patients. This is also about our energy crisis and our environment. Legalization is the key to opening up research into the real value of this versatile plant. We could replace corn with this hearty weed and get twice as much fuel without sapping the land of its natural resources. We could stop cutting down trees and use this plant for any and all  paper products. This plant is the key to a 'Greener' future. Our environment is suffering right now because of all the extra chemicals needed to process trees into paper, emissions from gas and oil burning cars and the pharmaceuticals that end up in our drinking water.

I really do not understand why anyone thinks our new president is going to be the one to 'change' our nations policy regarding this plant. Too many people in high places will lose a lot of business if this plant is decriminalized. Paper companies, chemical companies, pharmaceutical companies, oil companies and illegal drug pushers will lose billions.

It will never be decriminalized as long the citizens of this nation continue to give up all the power that the constitution gives them. One voice may not be heard but a large group shouting is unmistakable.

Who was it that said a nation of people that let their civil liberties be taken away for temporary safety deserve neither safety nor civil liberties. I believe that was Benjamen Franklin. Yet, so many people voted for the patriot act. So as far as Ben is concerned no one who voted for the patriot act deserves safety or liberty. Thank goodness I did not vote for it.

For those of you that think this is a joke you should really do your research before you go spouting off at the mouth. Start with a search on Google or Yahoo for Granny Storm Crow. You will be educated and enlightened. I encourage you do get educated before you post again.

This is no laughing matter. Legalization is the key to changing everything in our future. The economy, the environment and the community. So get on board or get out of the way.

Joe.J
January 14, 2009 2:54 PM

CNBC will be premiering Marijuana Inc. Inside America’s Pot Industry on Thursday, January 22nd at 9p ET / 10p PT. The marijuana trade has long been one of the country’s leading black market industries. What factors continue to help this taboo business thrive and how is the government profiting as a result?  Join Trish Regan as she explores this growing industry and how it has expanded into a major business with its own sophisticated network of growers, workers, and quasi-legal retail outlets, in the form of medical marijuana dispensaries.

Web extras are coming soon to http://originals.cnbc.com.  

Sneak preview on Hulu: www.hulu.com/.../cnbc-originals-marijuana-inc-inside-americas-pot-industry

Thanks

Kevin

Todd l
January 24, 2009 8:48 PM

Yup, this article is way off and our friend Andy here is so out of touch, Poor Andy. Man! every one could vote on more than one answer. Yes of course there are more important issues, but none more WIDELY agreed upon than Herb. And you must not be too keen on history nor human behavior as well.  It will be these "tumultuous" times that will finally help put and end to it. When times are bad all men are forced to re-evaluate other potential sources of revenue. Pot fits right in that class. Herb is costing them money they no longer have and has the potential to fill the pockets they need filled. Check all the recent polls you can and you'll find there are not to many people left  with your opinion. Peace, Dr.Todd

About OhMyGov!

The most fun government news has ever been...

Read More
Press Coverage

Site Tools

An array of helpful, fun features is coming soon!


Friends

We're on Facebook and Twitter: @OhMyGov
and @Bureaupat

See Our Partners