An all-new OhMyGov! is here...

  JOIN  or  LOGIN    ALSO ON OMG! : GET SOCIAL
060126

Student arrested for passing gas in school

By Alex Salta Dec 08 2008, 09:56 AM

If Blazing Saddles taught us anything in the infamous "campfire scene," it is the simple truth that farts are funny.  But this rule of humor isn't recognized at Spectrum Junior-Senior High School in Stuart, Florida, where a 12-year-old student was arrested on November 4th for "disruption of a school function" after, according to a Martin County Sheriff's Office report, "deliberately passing gas to disrupt the class."

The student also turned off the computers of other students in his classroom, resulting in a disruption of class work. Consequently, he was sent to the school's Discipline Office where he admitted to the infraction and was subsequently placed under arrest by the Sheriff's officer assigned to the school.

A juvenile arrest affidavit was filed and the flatulent offender was released to his mother.

On the surface, the story is simply another what the gov? moment,  and a real gas of one. But after looking deeper, we uncovered that this past January, the Florida Department of Juvenile Justice presented Florida Governor Charlie Crist and the State Legislature with a Blueprint Commission report entitled Getting Smart About Juvenile Justice, which shows some disturbing trends in the punishment of adolescents.

 "Zero-tolerance laws and policies were intended to target more serious offenders involving weapons, drugs or violent acts," the report notes.  "Schools have expanded their use to include other, less serious offenses and behaviors, resulting in large numbers of youths being referred to the juvenile justice system."

The report's goal, according to the Commission's Chair, was to proactively prevent juvenile delinquency, by providing more appropriate, less restrictive sanctions for low-risk and misdemeanant youth offenders, focusing on rehabilitation, and "reserving serious sanctions for violent and habitual offenders."  In the report, the Commission recommended a re-structuring of the K-12 zero tolerance policies so minor offenses would not fall under the zero tolerance rule.  

Apparently, they left out passing gas from their list of minor offenses.

Zero tolerance policies are in place to deal with serious threats that can potentially impact the safety of the student population at-large. Remember all those reports of students being suspended for wearing black trench coats or listening to heavy metal during the height of post-Columbine hysteria? Apparently the Martin County School District doesn't.

By saddling law enforcement with small-time offenses such as breaking wind publicly, schools run the risk of overloading a system that would be better served by only confronting the pressing school safety issues. Perhaps the administrators at this school should invest their time in disseminating bottles of Pepto-Bismol and copies of Emily Post, instead of rap sheets.

 

Also Interesting:



Most Read:

Read More: What The Gov, Florida

 
 
 
Submit
COMMENT

Kevin Schieberl
May 14, 2009 12:45 AM

The disingenuousness of your title is saddening--because it both sensationalizes the issue and trivializes the real infraction (turning off computers) for which the student was rightly punished.

As a public school teacher, I'm at the sharp end of many of these policies.  They're egregious enough to stand on their own as a story without a cheap shock-journalism trick headline.  The only purpose that serves in the long run is to diminish your credibility and make it easier for those who should truly listen to dismiss you.

Bob Hudnall
May 16, 2009 9:53 AM

I am an old coot, but not so old that I can't recall many of my youthful indiscretions at school. If what this kid did was deserving of calling the cops then I surely should have been sentenced to life in detention without parole. That isn't, however, what happened. It was a less enlightened time and instead of being prosecuted for my childish offenses, I was sent to Mr. Grimes office. Mr. Grimes was a pro when it came to wielding a paddle and could get a young miscreant back on the straight and narrow...in our school, he was the law West of the Pecos.

If today's schools had more caring teachers and more paddle wielding principals like Mr. Grimes and fewer politically correct morons demanding that a guy with a gun be called things would be more as they should be.

Thank you, and God bless you Mr. Grimes.

L Wolfe
May 18, 2009 9:53 AM

I am sorry but turning off a computer is not a reason to arrest a child. Punishment of some sort yes but not arrested. It sounds as though the child was out of hand but come on people.

chris: one already exists www.totalrecallinfo.com  more SJ Suber: Create an independent exclusive personal barcode system that when an item is scanned at ac...  more Woodrow: Amazing technology, with nothing but wild claims and anecdotal evidence to back it up. The...  more

About OhMyGov!

The most fun government news has ever been...

Read More
Press Coverage

Site Tools

An array of helpful, fun features is coming soon!


Friends

We're on Facebook and Twitter: @OhMyGov
and @Bureaupat

See Our Partners