Follow OhMyGov! on  OhMyGov on Facebook

  JOIN  or  LOGIN    ALSO ON OMG! : GET SOCIAL
750558

Greening the Gov: Governments taking aim at plastic bags

By Andrew B. Einhorn Jul 28 2008, 10:18 AM

"Would you like paper or plastic?"

For years, we opted for plastic, even though the decision reminded us of the plastic bag menagerie exploding out from beneath our sinks. Sure, they are good for carrying pet products, lunches, and wet bathing suits, but who needs so many? We all mean to bring them back, to recycle them, but somehow the thought never registers prior to departing for the grocery store.  That luxury of being able to forget our bags may soon be coming to an end, as governments around the country and the world are trending towards banning or taxing the use of plastic (and sometimes paper) bags.

Late March of 2007, San Francisco became the first U.S. city to ban plastic bags, due to their inability to be recycled or decomposed in landfills easily and tendencies to blow into trees and waterways, where they are blamed for killing marine life. Stores now give out paper bags or plastic bags made from cornstarch that easily biodegrade when disposed of.

Those supporting the ban credit it with saving around 800,000 gallons of oil used to make the 180 million plastic bags handed out annually in San Francisco alone.  Four to five trillion nondegradable plastic bags are used worldwide annually.

Other towns in California have quickly followed suit.  Similar bans were enacted by Manhattan Beach, Malibu, and this week, Las Angeles opted to ban plastic bags by 2010.  Lt. Gov. John Garamendi, slated to vie for California's Governor in 2010, favors a statewide program to reduce marine debris that may include a California-wide plastic bag ban. 

Although the plastic bag ban was bucked recently in Baltimore, plenty of other governments have taken aim at these new and surprising icons of environmental destruction. In Ann Arbor, Michigan, City Council Member Stephen Rapundalo is pushing ahead with a proposal to ban plastic shopping bags. And on the other side of the world, China banned plastic bags in January of this year, claiming the move will save over 37 million barrels of oil. 

Given China's reputation as a major polluter, the ban came as a surprise to many.  But given our current oil crises, trends across the country, and our ever-shrinking cabinet space for grocery bags, perhaps this is one environmental policy we should adopt from China.

Read More: Business And Economy, Energy And Environment, Public Health, Legislation, California, Maryland, Michigan

 
 
 
Submit
COMMENT

KT
July 28, 2008 4:22 PM

I can't help but to point out a few misleading and deceptive claims from your above post. While many have indeed jumped on the bandwagon to ban plastic bags, unfortunately, we will learn down the road banning plastic bags would be the worst thing for our environment. Of course, the world would be a better place if people answered to the question "paper or plastic" with "NOTHING" and bring their own bags. But we're a society that is molded through convenience and laziness. This will need to change, our behavioral tendencies will need to dramatically improve. But having our government control a consumer and businesses right in choosing a paper or plastic bags is just a bit much. Plastic bags across the board are proven to be leaps and bounds more environmentally friendly than paper bags. Which is the alternative when plastic bag bans are put in place. Take for example Taiwan, they banned plastic bags, however they repealed the laws after their landfills were impacted within 1 year. You never hear this in the news?? The facts about paper are contrary to popular belief: 85 times more energy to produce paper. 70 percent more air pollution. 50 times more water pollutants. Takes up 25% of municipal waste in landfills, this is compared to plastic bags taking less than 5%. "Those supporting the ban credit it with saving around 800,000 gallons of oil used to make the 180 million plastic bags handed out annually in San Francisco alone. " The claim that plastic bags are "oil hogs" is untrue. There is a claim repeated over and over again on the Internet that plastic bags are made out of oil and that 12 million barrels of oil are used annually in the United States to make the plastic bags that Americans use. It is not true. Plastic bags are made out of polyethylene. Polyethylene is made of ethylene. In the United States, ethylene is made of ethane which is extracted from natural gas. As a result, plastic bags manufactured in the United States are not made out of oil. The ethane must be removed from the natural gas anyway to lower the BTU value of the natural gas to an acceptable level. Ethane burns too hot to be allowed to remain in high levels in natural gas that is delivered to homes and businesses for fuel. There is nothing else that the ethane can be used for except to make ethylene. If ethane is not used to make plastic, it will have to be burned off, resulting in greenhouse gas emissions. Using the ethane to make plastic does not in any way reduce the amount of fuel available for transportation or power generation or increase our energy imports. If we were to abolish plastic bags, it would have zero impact on our dependence on foreign oil. The United States is an exporter of polyethylene. The United States imports virtually no polyethylene. "Stores now give out paper bags or plastic bags made from cornstarch that easily biodegrade when disposed of." This claim above is also not accurate. Any bag that is biodegradable made of corn based products, sugarcane etc is NOT easily biodegradable. In order for them to biodegrade they need to be collected at a controlled facility. This means, bags that go to landfills, end up as littler, or any other place that does not have commercial composting will NEVER degrade. In addition not to breaking down, they cannot be recycled which in my eyes is the worst of all evils. Today's scientific advances has now allowed normal plastic bags to biodegrade. There is an additive that can be added that has proven to brerakdown faster than paper. And, most importantly, you can RECYCLE the bags which should be the first choice for any product, paper or plastic! Much of my information has come from our www.EPA.gov website. Also handy websites for factual and proven information can be found at www.Savetheplasticbag.com. My education is in environmental chemistry, with a MS in environmental engineering. Its shameful for me to see so many people with such misleading information try and ban a product innovation such as plastic. Let's take self responsibility, which our society has somehow lost touch with, and being reusing and recycling. Thank you, KT

On The Horizon
July 29, 2008 10:42 AM

You've seen its utility for the soldier, the car, and the cell phone; now GPS (Global Positioning

Sustainable city? Let’s send a message in a (banned) bottle « Left eye on Vancouver: keeping a critical eye on municipal politics
July 29, 2008 10:03 PM

Pingback from  Sustainable city? Let’s send a message in a (banned) bottle « Left eye on Vancouver: keeping a critical eye on municipal politics

California eyeing high-speed rail to ease traffic and gas costs - On The Horizon
July 31, 2008 9:26 AM

Pingback from  California eyeing high-speed rail to ease traffic and gas costs - On The Horizon

Greening the Gov: Vermont continues innovative energy program - State and Local
August 1, 2008 10:17 AM

Pingback from  Greening the Gov: Vermont continues innovative energy program - State and Local

pet stores manhattan
September 12, 2008 4:44 AM

Pingback from  pet stores manhattan

 

         

 

 

                JOIN THE COMMUNITY!
 
 

 

sick of lies: my mom has cancer was a nurse 30 years has 1 years for medicare and her retierment kicks i...  more Janelle: The City of San Francisco is currently using Brightidea's WebStorm solution to power a...  more dxviper15: they took our jobs!!!!!!!!  more

About OhMyGov!

The most fun government news has ever been...

Read More
Press Coverage

Site Tools

An array of helpful, fun features is coming soon!


Friends

We're on Facebook and Twitter: @OhMyGov
and @Bureaupat

See Our Partners